[ Listen on Apple Podcasts ] [ Other Options ]
Grace in relationships means seeing intent, not just words. Why we misread struggles, and how Compassion restores connection.
When Empathy Misses the Mark: Why We Misread Struggles
“How dare you try to compare a dislocated finger to a broken femur! You have no idea what I’m going through! You’re so insensitive!” I said. Politely.
“Oh… n-no…” they stammered as they shook their head, “I just mean… wi-with the x-ray machine…” and so on and so on.
“Trying to compare something so trivial to the pain I’m in! You should be ashamed of yourself!”
And, boy… did they look it. Then again, maybe that wasn’t shame. Maybe it was something else. Because they just shook their head in disappointment, turned right around and walked straight out the door.
Leaving me there. Alone. With a broken femur. Which definitely did not feel anything like a dislocated finger. Or so I assumed.
To a certain degree, I suspect this is a scenario you’ve encountered. You share a deeply personal or painful experience, or talk about a very difficult struggle, only to be met with responses that fall short of offering the comfort or understanding you had hoped for. Maybe they say something that feels dismissive or unrelated (“Oh I went through a similar thing with my cat. I’m so sorry about your mother.”) Maybe they jump into a story about their own experience, as if it can match or explain what you’re feeling (“When my college girlfriend and I broke up after two years, that felt a lot like a divorce. She took my cat.”)
In moments like this, it’s easy to assume the worst. You think they’re trivializing your pain, misunderstanding you, or even disinterested. Yet, what if that isn’t the case at all? What if, instead of minimizing your struggles, they’re genuinely trying to relate? Maybe, just maybe, they’re offering the best they can from where they stand—from the lens of their own life experiences.
Why We Assume the Worst And How Empathy Falls Short
Here’s the thing: people can only relate as far as their own experiences. That doesn’t mean they don’t care. It doesn’t mean they’re intentionally dismissive or unaware of the gravity of what we’re sharing. It just means that their empathy is limited by the scope of their understanding.
Life is messy. We all walk different paths, with highs and lows, joys and sorrows that uniquely shape who we are. This individuality, while beautiful, creates barriers in understanding. No two people will ever fully understand each other’s experiences, because they’re not living in each other’s shoes.
But in our moments of vulnerability, we often expect the impossible. We expect others to fully grasp what we’re going through, to give us the right words or actions that make everything feel validated. (I mean, if you’re married, this is kind of an everyday occurrence). And when they don’t, disappointment settles in. We think, “How could they not get it? How could they say something so off-base? I don’t think a cat even has a femur.”
The problem, though, isn’t always with them. Sometimes it’s in our expectations. (Or our surprisingly limited knowledge of feline biology). We hold others to a standard of empathy that may not be fair, given their own life experiences. Their ability to support us is inherently shaped by their story, not ours.
But… C’mon! I want it to be about me!
Quelle surprise! This can create friction in relationships. When we share our pain, sadness, or even joy, we want to be heard and understood. We crave that deep, resonant connection where someone says, “I get you, Boo.” But often, what we get instead is a reply that feels far removed from our emotional state. A reply that doesn’t touch the depth of what we’re feeling.
This misunderstanding can breed resentment. We start to distance ourselves emotionally, thinking that the person on the other side doesn’t care or doesn’t understand. Or, in some cases, we use this misunderstanding as a means to separate ourselves further from someone we’re angry with. Or someone we’re opposed to.
The truth, however, might be something far more Compassionate in nature. That person on the other side might not be insensitive, after all. They may not be trying to belittle you. They might be doing the best they can with the emotional tools they have. They might be trying to connect with us using the only reference point they know: their own life.
Give the Benefit of the Doubt: Seeing Intent with Grace
What if we shifted our perspective? What if, instead of reacting with frustration or disappointment, (or with the assumption they’re trying to be hurtful), we took a step back and considered that maybe they’re genuinely trying to understand us? Maybe they’re doing their best to navigate the conversation, to offer comfort or connection from a place that’s familiar to them.
This isn’t about lowering our standards for meaningful communication or accepting subpar empathy. It’s about recognizing that people, in their essence, are limited by what they’ve known and felt. Their responses are shaped by the framework of their own experiences.
When someone tries to relate to us by offering a story of their own, even if it doesn’t quite match the gravity of our situation, it’s their way of saying, “I’m here. I’ve felt something similar, and I want you to know you’re not alone.” They might not be able to fully grasp the nuance of our pain, but they’re reaching out in the best way they know how.
Instead of dismissing these attempts, we can embrace them as acts of care. Yes, even when they are coming from people we think wouldn’t care. We can choose to give them the benefit of the doubt. Perhaps they don’t have the right words, but they’re trying to show up for us in the way they know how.
When we shift our focus from what they didn’t say to the intent behind their words, we open up new possibilities for connection. We create space for empathy and Compassion, even when it doesn’t come wrapped in the exact package we expect. That can be a fun—and unexpected—little gift to open!
How to Practice Grace Daily: Reframe, Listen, Communicate
How do we put this into practice in our relationships?
It begins with reframing. When someone responds to us in a way that doesn’t quite hit the mark, instead of immediately feeling disappointed or misunderstood, we can pause. Take a moment to ask ourselves, “What are they really trying to say? Are they trying to relate, even if it doesn’t quite fit? What’s this whole cat thing about?”
Giving others the benefit of the doubt is an act of Grace. It’s acknowledging that we’re all human, and we’re all doing our best to navigate the complexities of life and relationships. This doesn’t mean we shouldn’t seek deeper understanding or more meaningful connections. It means we allow room for imperfection.
We can also communicate our needs more clearly. If we’re feeling unheard or misunderstood, instead of withdrawing or getting defensive, we can gently explain what we need. “I appreciate that you’re trying to relate, but I really just need someone to listen right now. And also: Meow.” (Again… married folks raise your hand!) By doing this, we bridge the gap between their experience and our own.
It’s also helpful to remember that Compassion is a skill, one that some people naturally excel at while others may need more practice. Not everyone will know how to hold space for us in the way we desire. But if we can see their efforts as genuine, even if imperfect, we can foster healthier, more understanding relationships.
And think about the fun conversations and stories that can open up; the new things you can learn about a person!
Ultimately, none of us are immune to the limitations of our own experiences. We all approach others with a set of assumptions, shaped by our own lives. When we extend Grace to others, we’re also extending it to ourselves. We’re admitting that, just as they may struggle to fully understand us, we, too, might not always get it right when the roles are reversed.
No… I never broke my femur. But I did once dislocate a finger.
In the end, relationships aren’t about perfect understanding. They’re about mutual effort, kindness, and the willingness to keep showing up for one another, even when the road to connection is a little rocky. It’s about giving people—even those you wouldn’t think could or should—the opportunity to surprise you.
When we give others the benefit of the doubt, we create a space where empathy, however flawed, can grow into something more beautiful and meaningful than we might have first imagined.
Life doesn’t come with a guidebook on how to relate to one another perfectly. But with patience, communication, Compassion, and the Grace to let others try, even if they don’t always get it right, we can foster deeper, more resilient connections. So the next time someone doesn’t quite seem to “get it,” pause. Consider their heart. Give them the benefit of the doubt. After all, they’re only human, just like you.
Share
Have you ever had an experience like this before? If so, from which perspective? Or have you experienced it from both? What was that like? Additionally, within the context of today’s cultural and political division, how might you implement the suggestions in this article to better offer Grace and understanding to people on the “other side”? Share your thoughts and experiences below!